“It’s not us… all this mucking about with our sound.”  

Sunny Afternoon is about many things. This is in so many ways a rock concert – with a score that makes it impossible not to dance and clap along in your seat. It’s vibrant – with a talented design team that simply does not hold back as they bring this musical to life, especially with Costume Designer Miriam Buether’s 60s looks. It’s also joy, with Adam Cooper’s choreography that fills the stage, complete with favorite moves of the decade.

However, at its root, this is the origin story of a rock band. Like so many true stories in this genre, you witness the highs and lows – particularly when the men realize that fame doesn’t quite feel as any of them may have anticipated. As Ray Davies (Danny Horn) frustratingly admits the above on a phone call with his band manager, Larry Page (Sean Fortunato), you may find yourself leaning in, wondering if the group can salvage the heart of their music before it’s too late.

With book by Joe Penhall and music, lyrics, and original story by Ray Davies himself, Sunny Afternoon features the origin story of The Kinks – a British rock band in the 60s. We meet the musicians when they are in essence teenagers – Ray Davies (Danny Horn), Dave Davies (Oliver Hoare), Peter Quaife (Michael Lepore), and Mick Avory (Kieran McCabe). Once they are discovered, their fame skyrockets – with hordes of fans only wanting more with every tour and drop of a new album. Like what many might expect, fame isn’t always easy, and audiences have a front-row seat to the many nuances that can come with that as the story unfolds.

Directed by Artistic Director Edward Hall, Sunny Afternoon is a jukebox musical featuring a number of hits from The Kinks including “You Still Want Me,” “Lola,” “A Rock’n’roll Fantasy,” and “Waterloo Sunset.”  The production showcases a strong ensemble – particularly in the four actors embodying the members of The Kinks. It is not easy to find performers who can not only act the roles, but also play their instruments with a high level of expertise and sing in a way that resembles the original members. To say that the casting was spot-on is an understatement, and from the cheers and applause surrounding me at this performance, it seems fair to say that the audience agreed.

The music alone is a blast, and fans of The Kinks or any rock concert are sure to have a fun night. However, especially for the dedicated theater-goers in the audience, you might find that what really sells the show is the chemistry between the performers at the center.

“Dedicated Follower of Fashion” is a prime example appearing early in Act One. The young band members find themselves in a department store confronting one of the first shifts that they would have to endure on the way to stardom – finding their new look. Their new management tries to force them down a specific path of a classy, formal appearance. However, the men cannot help but turn the experience into something else entirely. Throughout the song, we see them having fun with different looks – joking around with different accessories and making it clear to all involved that they are here for the joy. The audience at this performance was clearly along for the ride – laughing alongside the actors and cheering as they made the number increasingly over-the-top.

The Kinks did not have it easy – and Sunny Afternoon certainly makes that clear. Particularly as the pressures become too much for some of the band members, the story can be hard to swallow. However, much of that is due to the genuine friendship we witness unfold on stage. Hall’s ensemble brings an authenticity that you might just find is impossible not to love.

Stellar casting and a rocking score make Sunny Afternoon a theatrical event that you simply do not want to miss. Whether you are a die-hard Kinks fan or this is your first time experiencing the material, the music alone will leave you wanting more.

HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

Run Time: 2 hours and 30 minutes, with intermission

Sunny Afternoon runs at Chicago Shakespeare Theater (800 E Grand Avenue) through April 27, 2025. See the Chicago Shakespeare Theater website for more information regarding tickets.