A title like “Swing State” is certainly provocative and might suggest exactly what Rebecca Gilman’s new play is about, but oddly enough it’s not about an election. Two of Chicago’s best actresses; Mary Beth Fisher and Kristen Fitzgerald join director Robert Falls in this much-anticipated production at Goodman Theatre. Chicago-based playwright Rebecca Gilman has had a long history of collaborating with Goodman, Robert Falls and Mary Beth Fisher. This is the tenth play they’ve produced, and many have been directed by Falls and, or starred Fisher. “Swing State” is another riveting script from the Pulitzer-nominated playwright.
Somewhere on the driftless land of Wisconsin, recently widowed Peg (Mary Beth Fisher) lives alone on a large patch of remnant prairie land. When a box of old tools and a gun go missing from Peg’s barn, she enlists the sheriff (Kristen Fitzgerald) and her well-meaning but dopey deputy Dani (Anne E Thompson). They suspect a community “screw-up” named Ryan (Bubba Weiler) who Peg and her late husband had mentored. Though Peg doesn’t want to pursue it, the sheriff is relentless.
Despite its fast moving 95-minute runtime, “Swing State” takes a few hours to digest. What Gilman exceeds at is taking broad political issues and distilling them through the individual experience. Much of her parallels are drawn through metaphor. The prairie land Peg so meticulously tends to represent an uncorrupted way of life vanishing in the American heartland. Gilman also shines a light on the police ineptitude and cruelty running rampant in smalltown Midwestern communities.
Mary Beth Fisher embodies the beleaguered Peg. Her physicality tells an entire story without saying a word. Though, it’s in a single, lengthy monolog in which she effortlessly flows through the realm of emotions that she gets to the real depths of her character. Kristen Fitzgerald is also a thundering presence as the zealous smalltown sheriff, Kris. It’s clear Fitzgerald has a good understanding of the kind of corrupting ignorance plaguing our justice system. While neither character is without flaws, these two actresses have approached their roles with compassion, which serves the nuances of the ending.
“Swing State” is a shocking story that builds through quiet, often two-person scenes. Gilman does well to make her point while also staying true to her own life experiences. The title suggests that the rural Midwest is still a swayable population. In that idea alone the script points toward optimism. Peg’s character journey also suggests optimism even if the ending might seem unsettling. This is an honest play about the types of people you might meet in a small Midwestern community. There may not be an election in the play, but its looming consequences have colored every aspect of Gilman’s richly drawn world.
Through November 13th at Goodman Theatre. 170 N Dearborn St. www.goodmantheatre.org
