I have to admit up front - I am a full-on West Side Story fan girl. I have seen the movie, released in 1961, probably 100 times. I know the plot, the words to every song, the dance moves, and have viscerally felt the teenage angst that is the underlying basis of the plot...for well over 50 years. I credit Leonard Bernstein, Stephen Sondheim and the original writer, Arthur Laurents with kickstarting my love of all things Shakespeare (West Side Story is an updated take on Romeo and Juliet.) I kneel and utter multiple huzzahs to the brilliant Choreographer, Jerome Robbins who, for crying out loud - came up with moves so outrageous and fluid that every dance inspired child of the early 1960’s spent hours learning how to snap their fingers below their knees as they moved stealthily forward while trying to control their rage.
Yes, I am a fan. And as some would say an obsessively, vested fan...I can honestly state that The Lyric Opera of Chicago’s production of West Side Story is spot on. It will not let you down. While it is comforting in its homage to the original Broadway play and subsequent movie, it adds some little idiosyncrasies of its own that makes you nod and realize that yep, this stuff is still going on-500 plus years after Shakespeare conceived of star-crossed lovers and the intolerance of bigotry.
Now, down to the meat of this production.
Mikaela Bennett as Maria, displays the full range of emotions of a young, protected yet curious girl, new to the reality and struggle of leaving her home and trying to break free to embrace her pending adulthood and new life. Ms. Bennett’s vocal range is mesmerizing. She has a clarity to her notes you rarely hear outside of traditional opera. She also personifies the innocence and joie de vivre of a girl stepping forward to become a woman. She is a lovely actress, and her Maria goes deep to the heart.Corey Cott, as Tony steps up into the role that Richard Beymer stamped into our consciousness. He steps up, and over. Realistically, the role written as Tony is kind of light, dialog-wise. But Mr. Cott’s voice is so deceptively amazing, it leaves one almost breathless. The man has mastered the “Devil’s Triangle” of notes. Kudos, Sir. You made us cry.
Amanda Castro as Anita is edgy, punky and truly inhabits a proud Borinquena taking control of her life and love. She has the fricative vocal ability to really emphasize her strength and make you feel that whatever comes out of her mouth should be stamped with an exclamation point!
Manuel Stark Santos as Bernardo, though he doesn’t really have any musical solos-is a presence on stage in and of himself. His big brother slash gang leader is dominating and realistically embodies the macho-ness of Hispanic culture. This is no George Chakiris in brown face...this is an actor who shows us on stage what cultural machismo entails.
Brett Thiele as Riff is more talented, vocally pleasing and better looking than the movie version. He shows us a few more layers into a character that has been generally portrayed as depth-light.
The remainder of the cast is talented and on point in their portrayal as followers to the main characters. All are in of themselves wonderful singers and dancers, and they do this production proud.
The production and stage crew were fluid, efficient and cohesive. I really enjoyed how symbiotic the set changes were. It’s probably one of the more demanding jobs and they did it faultlessly.
Lastly...the orchestra conducted by James Lowe was, as to be expected - stellar. Ladies and gentlemen, you took my breath away.
All in all. I highly recommend The Lyric’s production of West Side Story. For a tragic story, it left me full of joy.
Through June 2nd at Lyric Opera of Chicago.
