It’s that spooky time of year when we crave cheap candy and scary movies, and when deserted storefronts suddenly pop their doors open to sell Halloween costumes. Strawdog Theatre Company launches its 31st season with the world premiere of Masque Macabre, a Halloween-y show inspired by the works of Edgar Allan Poe. Written by ensemble members Aly Greaves Amidei and John Henry Roberts and company member Cara Beth Heath and directed by Co-Artistic Director Anderson Lawfer, Janet Howe and Eli Newell, Masque Macabre is an immersive theatre experience.
The play seems like quite an ambitious undertaking. Strawdog Theatre has converted its entire space into a colorful house (scenic design by Tom Burch, props design by Lacie Hexom), set as a farewell party for a young filthy rich entrepreneur. Every room has a purpose: there’s one with a mad alchemist mixing colorful liquids and talking to a creature in a fish bowl, an antique bath tub perfect for storing a dead body, a room with dozens of human skulls made of glass. It sounds like fun.
Before the show even starts, the actors and audience hang out in the theatre lobby. Like with many haunted houses the audience is asked to sign non-disclosure waivers but are then shown a short video/ introduction and given masks to wear. We are encouraged to move around the house, following the drama that unfolds in real time. It starts out with a great promise of fun and there are a few rules to follow (“don’t touch anything’, “only speak when spoken to”, etc). There are fourteen horror stories to follow and many scary conversations to eavesdrop on. Actors dress as party guests (great costumes by Virginia Varland!) move between various rooms and closets enacting scenarios of revenge, murder, and other drama, occasionally engaging audience members in small talk and tasks, like holding a flash light.
In my opinion, immersive theatre, if done right, is the most exciting theatre entertainment there is. Plays like [last year’s] For One and [this year’s returning] Madness of Edgar Allan Poe: A Love Story are wonderfully creative and intense, and truly are an unforgettable experience. Unfortunately, Strawdog’s Masque Macabre lacked both the intensity and substance; there’re really no cohesive stories to follow, most dialogues are confusing, and actors seem to be at a loss for words a lot of times. And, most disappointing of all: it’s not even remotely scary, and that’s the real crime. In short, Strawdog’s Masque Macabre still needs to live up to its full potential in order to be the great immersive theatre experience we have come to expect from so much talent behind this production’s team. This production just never really comes together like one would hope. Lots of potential here. The idea is there, but it’s not quite ready. Strawdog has put forth many strong shows over the years, but I wouldn't be so quick to add this one to the list quite yet.
Masque Macabre is being performed at Strawdog Theatre through Halloween. For more info on this production visit https://strawdog.org.
