For more than 50 years, Tim Rice & Andrew Lloyd Webber’s powerful masterpiece, Jesus Christ Superstar, has wowed audiences with its unorthodox look at the life and persona of Jesus Christ through its soaring lyrics and driving rock score. And so, it is most appropriate that BrightSide Theatre concludes its 12th season, entitled “A Season of Passion,” with this impassioned classic rock opera.
From the iconic solo guitar rift to the poignant close as Mary, Jesus’ mother, cradles her crucified son’s head in her lap, BrightSide’s production at North Central College’s Meiley-Swallow Hall in Naperville provides a fast-paced and thoroughly entertaining evening powered by the strong vocal performances of the main cast and an exuberant ensemble.
The show, loosely based on the Gospels, focuses on the final days of Jesus’ life leading up to his crucifixion, as seen largely through the eyes of Judas Iscariot. At the heart of the story are the personal conflicts between Jesus, his disciples, the Jewish people, and the leadership of Rome, with special attention given to Jesus’ relationships with Judas and Mary Magdalene.
Conceived at first as a groundbreaking rock double-album in the early 70s, the music and lyrics by Rice and Webber, then only 25 and 21 respectively, has held up through the years. In BrightSide’s production, artistic Director Jeffrey Cass takes a contemporary approach to the show by imagining Jesus’ story in a modern setting, challenging the audience to consider how Jesus might be received in today’s culture.
To set the tone, the cast is clad in contemporary, edgy clothes and the set is minimal, utilizing metal scaffolding to flow from one scene to another. Cass also adds nice touches such as when the ensemble takes out their cell phones to record Jesus’ response after meeting with the Jewish High Priest, Caiaphas (played by Stan Austin). And, as what would be expected with any celebrity-sighting today, they jostle one another to grab a “selfie” with the proclaimed Messiah.
The only off-note for me was the wardrobe choice for Jesus, played by BrightSide veteran Edward MacLennan. While everyone else is edgy and modern, Jesus arrives on stage with what looked like a hooded bathrobe. I would have preferred him to have a more updated, dignified vibe than he did.
That aside, MacLennan turns in a masterful performance and demonstrates his incredible vocal range in two incredibly powerful scenes. In Act One, MacLennan captures Jesus’ passion and righteous anger in “The Temple,” and then his frustration as Jesus is overwhelmed by the needs of those clamoring for healing and help. In Act Two, MacLennan is outstanding as he portrays Jesus in Gethsemane, as Jesus struggles to comprehend and accept that path before him, his anguish palpable through MacLennan’s masterful vocalizations.
Turning in an equally strong performance is Michael Davis Arnold as Judas. Making his debut at BrightSide Theatre, Arnold’s strong and expressive vocals underscore his character’s personal doubts and questions about this man Jesus and his claims to be God. Arnold ably portrays Judas’ inner struggles, which come to a crashing climax as Judas, horrified by Jesus’ harsh treatment and the knowledge that he will forever be remembered as a traitor, can no longer live with his regrets. Encouraged by the three Tormentors (wonderfully performed by Kassidy Alderman, Amber Golich, and Julia Hope Budd), Judas kills himself.
Meghan Kessel, another BrightSide veteran, shines in her role as Mary Magdalene. Her beautiful and soulful rendition of “I Don’t Know How to Love Him,” possibly the show’s most well-known signature songs, does not disappoint. And Caleb Hand’s Herod is hilarious. Flanked by his party-loving court, Herod struts and postures across the stage as he tries to coax Jesus into doing just one little miracle for him.
The show is propelled by an excellent ensemble that moves adroitly from adoring crowd to questioning disciples to a jeering mob calling for Jesus’ crucifixion, driven by the choreography of Jake Ganzer. The ensemble and cast are backed up by a talented group of musicians, under the experienced direction of Phil Videckis.
The show explodes into a glittering climax as the ensemble, led by Judas’ spirit, performs the title song, “Superstar,” questioning Jesus’ plan and purpose in coming to the world when he did before the dramatic closing as Jesus is led to the cross and put to death.
For those who grew up listening to the album as well as newcomers to this iconic rock opera, BrightSide’s entertaining rendition of Jesus Christ Superstar is a must-see production and well worth the trip to the western suburbs. You can catch Jesus Christ Superstar at North Central’s Theatre at Meiley-Swallow Hall, 31 S. Ellsworth, Naperville, now through June 23. Ticket information can be found at www.BrightSidetheatre.com or by phone at 630-447-TIXS (8497).
