
Erik Gernand is resident playwright at Redtwist Theatre, and his Prayer Circle is absolutely laugh-out-loud funny. The strength of this script is the characters—who are clearly defined and familiar types—and the performances, directed by Dusty Brown, are uniformly outstanding.
Set in the cramped loft of a church (with stained glass and roof vaults dominating a well-detailed set by Jeff Bain), we will meet the five members of the Prayer Circle (they call themselves “prayer warriors” for reasons that later become apparent) as they gather one by one for their spiritual endeavor. Doug (Kevin Waters) is already there when the lights come up, at the piano, singing carefully, spiritually (a snippet of the hymn "Blessed Assurance" I believe) with a beauty and intensity that suggests the conviction of the group we are to meet.
Waters’ singing is so good, conveying that his character Doug is intensely immersed in this vocal invocation he is caught off guard by the arrival of the irreverent Addy (Andi Muriel), who also happens to be his high school student in daily life.

Muriel is a very good comedic actor, and her Addy dispels the possibility of too much seriousness as she conveys the quick-witted slapdash humor that can spring forth when young people have discovered the absurdity of the adults governing them. We also meet Carol (Macaria Chaparro Martinez), a 30-something enveloped in a cloud of earnestness: “You can call me Bible lady just don’t call me late for prayer circle.”
Soon enough Marilyn (Jacqueline Grandt) lands, that familiar church matron who is far more powerful than she should be, perfectly coiffed and clad with a designer bag. There is still one seat vacant, a result of the tragic death by cancer of a young mother DeeDee, who we learn was the wife of Pastor Evans (Phillip C. Matthews).
Marilyn is all in a dither, because the president declared a war last night in a televised speech. Marilyn tells the circle that she has summoned Pastor Evens to address the matter with the prayer circle, calling him from his bereavement leave, and the care of his motherless children. What could possess her to do such a thing?
We soon discover this prayer circle wields unusual powers with its prayers and hopes to enlist the involvement of the pastor in its spiritual work. Gernand’s script stumbles a bit in its structure, with a tad more procrastination in the plot reveals than a screwball comedy like this warrants.
We also don’t see the moral analysis that the playwright seems to want to make the characters face. The playwright seems uncertain about how seriously we are to consider morality when he brushes against serious concerns encountered by these faithful.
Nevertheless, the tremendous comic performances, especially by Jacqueline Grandt and Andi Muriel, make this a show worth seeing. Prayer Circle, running through November 8, 2026 at Chicago's Redtwist Theatre, comes recommended.
Award-winning Redtwist Theatre’s new 22nd season, “State of Violence,” begins with Prayer Circle, September 17 - November 8, by Erik Gernand and directed by Executive Artistic Director Dusty Brown, at Redtwist Theatre, 1044 W. Bryn Mawr Ave. Preview performances are Thursday, Sept. 17, Friday, Sept. 18 and Saturday, Sept. 19 at 7:30 p.m. Regular performance schedule includes Thursdays through Saturdays at 8 p.m. and Sundays at 3:30 p.m. Single tickets are on sale starting August 15 for $50 (seniors and veterans: $35; students: $10 and Fridays are Pay-What-You-Can) with subscriptions also available at RedtwistTheatre.org.
As the world hurtles ever faster in the wrong direction, Addy discovers she may have the power to make it better. Joining with the members of a small town prayer circle, four people try to convince their pastor to pray with them… to bring about some killer results. Erik Gernand, Redtwist’s resident playwright, invites audiences to a darkly comedic debate - how far would you go to save your country?
The cast of Prayer Circle includes Jaqueline Grandt* (Marilyn); Philip Matthews* (Pastor Evans); Andi Muriel (Addy); Kezia Waters (Doug); Macaria Chaparro Martinez* (Carol); Natalie Rae (Marilyn U/S); Jeff Menezes (Pastor Evans U/S); Jessie Skonesey (Addy U/S) and Marco Antonio Perez (Doug U/S).
The creative team of Prayer Circle includes Erik Gernand (playwright); Dusty Brown (director); Joshua Servantez (assistant director); Jeff Brain* (scenic designer); Leo Bassow* (props designer); Piper Kirchhoffer* (lighting designer); Madeline Felauer (costume designer) and Charlie Tolbert (production manager).
*denotes Redtwist Theatre Ensemble Member
ABOUT ERIK GERNAND, playwright
Erik Gernand is a Chicago-based playwright and filmmaker. His play The Totality of All Things won a Jeff Award for Best New Work for its 2024 production at Redtwist Theatre where he is the playwright in residence. His plays have been produced around the country, including at The Barrow Group (New York City), The ROAD Theatre Company (Los Angeles) and City Theatre (Miami) and have been published by Dramatic Publishing and Smith & Kraus. His award-winning short films have screened at more than 100 film festivals around the world including SXSW, Cinequest, Outfest and the Chicago International Film Festival and have been broadcast on IFC, PBS and The Logo Channel. Gernand is a professor of instruction in radio-TV-film at Northwestern University.
ABOUT DUSTY BROWN, director
Dusty Brown is the executive artistic director of Redtwist Theatre. They began their career as a stage hand in Atlanta, Georgia, working on everything from Shakespeare to new works, and everything in between. They received their MFA in directing from Ohio University in 2021. Notable productions include: Steve Yockey's Wolves at Redtwist and Pluto at Ohio University; William Shakespeare's Macbeth at Three Crows and Ohio University; Tracy Letts' Bug at Ohio University; Stephen Sondheim's Sweeney Todd at DramaTech in Atlanta; Uffizi at Bottled Lightning in Atlanta and Neil Simon's Barefoot in the Park at Vox Populi Productions in Chattanooga.
The 2026 - 2027 Redtwist Theatre season also includes:
SHOW TWO - TO BE ANNOUNCED
January 28 - March 14, 2027
Previews: Thursday, Jan. 28 - Saturday, Jan. 30 at 7:30 p.m.
Opening Night: Sunday, Jan. 31 at 3:30 p.m.
Performance Schedule: Thursdays through Saturdays at 8 p.m. and Sundays at 3:30 p.m.
Tickets: $50 (seniors and veterans: $35; students: $10 and Fridays are Pay-What-You-Can)
Single tickets go on sale Saturday, Aug. 15
Redtwist Theatre will be announcing the second production at a later date.
Julius Caesar
April 8 - May 30, 2027
Written by William Shakespeare
Previews: Thursday, April 8 - Saturday, April 10 at 7:30 p.m.
Opening Night: Sunday, April 11 at 3:30 p.m.
Performance Schedule: Thursdays through Saturdays at 8 p.m. and Sundays at 3:30 p.m.
Tickets: $50 (seniors and veterans: $35; students: $10 and Fridays are Pay-What-You-Can)
Single tickets go on sale Saturday, Aug. 15
“Friends, Romans, Countrymen…” Something’s rotten in the republic. Most people know what happened on the Ides of March, but do they remember what came next? Join Redtwist in a riveting new take on Shakespeare’s classic story of political violence and its consequences.
Twisted Tuesday New Play Readings
Tuesdays at 7 p.m.
On select Tuesdays, Redtwist welcomes audiences for a new play reading from a variety of Chicago-based playwrights. All readings are Pay-What-You-Can.
One-On-Wednesday
Wednesdays at 7:30 p.m.
For three years, each Wednesday, Redtwist invites unique solo performers to take over its space and bring their singular, edgy perspective to the black box in Edgewater. All performances are Pay-What-You-Can.
Twisted PlayFest
Summer 2027
Returning for its third season, Twisted PlayFest is a new play incubator that provides ongoing play readings and development for aspiring Chicago playwrights. The centerpiece of this initiative is the annual Twisted Play Festival. The festival features ten plays at various stages of development.
ABOUT REDTWIST THEATRE
Redtwist is an award-winning theatre company that has for 22 seasons staged up close and personal contemporary dramas annually in its intimate black box theatre housed proudly within the heart of Edgewater’s Bryn Mawr Historic District.
Performances at Redtwist are designed to place the theatre patron in the midst of the stories being told, making them accessible and riveting. Redtwist strives for excellence with every project and endeavors to take risks while offering opportunities for up-and-coming actors, designers and directors to work with established talent. Redtwist provides the very best Chicago storefront theatre experience from excellence on stage, to warm hospitality in a clean, friendly environment.
Award-winning Redtwist Theatre’s new 22nd season, “State of Violence,” begins with Prayer Circle, September 17 - November 8, by Erik Gernand and directed by Executive Artistic Director Dusty Brown at Redtwist Theatre, 1044 W. Bryn Mawr Ave. Preview performances are Thursday, Sept. 17, Friday, Sept. 18 and Saturday, Sept. 19 at 7:30 p.m. Regular performance schedule includes Thursdays through Saturdays at 8 p.m. and Sundays at 3:30 p.m. Single tickets are on sale starting August 15 for $50 (seniors and veterans: $35; students: $10 and Fridays are Pay-What-You-Can) with subscriptions also available at RedtwistTheatre.org.
STEP RIGHT UP AND RIDE THE CYCLONE (THE MUSICAL) AT METROPOLIS ARLINGTON HEIGHTS
Funny ‘Prayer Circle’ Is Loaded With Laughs
American Blues Theater hosts its annual costumed fundraiser HALLOWEEN BOO BASH October 25th
Acclaimed Mexodus musical makes Chicago premiere November 7-21 at Studebaker Theater
Does your theatre company want to connect with Buzz Center Stage or would you like to reach out and say "hello"? Message us through facebook or shoot us an email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
*This disclaimer informs readers that the views, thoughts, and opinions expressed in the text belong solely to the author, and not necessarily to Buzz Center Stage. Buzz Center Stage is a non-profit, volunteer-based platform that enables, and encourages, staff members to post their own honest thoughts on a particular production.