It’s dark on the Neverland ship, and Molly, Prentis, Ted, and Boy are hiding in a corner – waiting for the coast to clear. As they huddle and watch, the four begin talking about dreams. All have experienced their fair share of hardships, but for the briefest moment, they look to a world of what could be.
Boy has been fairly quiet to this point – only following Molly with the promise of better food. However, at this discussion, he perks up, and whispers his dream aloud:
“The world will be so beautiful that no one will ever have to say sorry again.”
Many of us know the story of Peter Pan. The story of a boy who never wanted to grow up. All he wants is to fly around Neverland with the Lost Boys – fighting Pirates and finding adventure after adventure. The heart of the story is full of magic, and all the wonderful possibilities that come with a youthful energy and imagination.
Being a prequel to the famous tale (and based on the novel by Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson), Peter and the Starcatcher carries much of the same wonder. As Boy whispers his dream to the audience, you might find yourself reminded of that original story. Perhaps if you, like myself, grew up a fan of Peter Pan, you will even find yourself smiling and leaning in upon hearing the sweet innocence of the fantasy. Even in a moment where everything feels dark and uncertain, Boy, dares to dream – exploring a childlike wonder that so many eventually lose, but to which can be so fun to return.
Peter and the Starcatcher follows Boy (or later named Peter – played by Terry Bell), who is held captive on the Neverland ship with two fellow orphans - Prentis (Michaela Shaprio) and Ted (Brandon Acosta). When they meet Stardust Apprentice Molly (Shelbi Voss), their whole world is turned upside down. A quest for better food turns into an unexpected adventure when Pirates come on board – attempting to steal back a trunk full of precious stardust, which Molly and her father are sworn to protect. Drawn to Molly’s heroism, Boy takes it upon himself to protect this stardust at all costs – even if it means going toe to toe with Pirates and a terrifying ocean.
Directed by Nate Cohen, Paramount Theatre’s intimate production is intensely theatrical. Rick Elice’s play carries a storybook charm, with various forms of narration throughout and actors playing multiple roles depending on the needs of the moment. Sometimes actors step out of the action to narrate the next event, while other characters have moments of speaking in third person. Cohen and his team lean into the storybook feel – particularly in the collaboration between Scenic Designer Myra G Reavis and Props Designer Ivy Treccani. The set is minimalistic, and primarily comprised of various objects one might find in a theater. Ladders, stools, sheets, and chairs are utilized in multiple ways to represent various locations – all moved by the actors themselves. The effect? The audience is witnessing the story unfold and reconfigure in front of them with each scene, creating the feel of being inside the storybook alongside the characters. We are invited to use our imagination alongside the performers to fill in the dots, and with the intimate feel of Paramount’s Copley Theatre space, you might find that this adds to the experience.
As many of us know, Peter Pan is full of magic, and Peter and the Starcatcher is much the same. Lighting Designer Jackie Fox utilizes gold fairy lights to create the illusion of stardust – creating stunning stage pictures throughout the production.
One such moment occurs towards the end of the first act. Boy asks Molly for proof of what stardust can do. If he is going to risk his life to save it, then he may as well know why. Begrudgingly, Molly takes out her stardust, and whispers the following:
“To have faith is to have wings.”
From there, the surrounding lights dim and the specks of gold brighten. Molly is lifted above by actors, and as we see her spread her arms, Boy looks up in pure awe. Voss and Bell play the moment wonderfully – particularly as Voss’ Molly enjoys the feel of proving Bell wrong when he doubts her abilities. Most impressive though, at least personally, is the way in which Cohen stages the magic. As we see Molly lifted above by her ensemble, we too are invited to use our imagination - to have faith. From there, Cohen once again invites the audience to return to their own childhoods and enjoy the magic of storytelling and believing in the impossible.
Full of stunning performances and remarkable stage magic, Peter and the Starcatcher will leave you on the edge of your seat – eager for what’s next and wishing there was more beyond the final lights down.
Peter and the Starcatcher runs at Paramount Theatre’s Copley Theatre – 8 E Galena Blvd in Aurora through September 1, 2024. See the Paramount Theatre Website for tickets and information.
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
After many years without seeing the movie or reading the story of Peter Pan, the moment I learned that Peter Pan: The Hit Broadway Musical was coming to Chicago, my inner child couldn’t contain its excitement. I arrived at the James M. Nederlander Theatre, quickly found my seat, and noticed joyful children surrounding me. The adults were definitely outnumbered, but hey, we are still kids at heart and have imagination, too! As expected, on opening night, the theater was filled to capacity, and excitement was palpable.
As the lights dim, theatregoers are welcomed into the shared childhood bedroom of Wendy, John, and Michael. Their parents, preparing for an event that evening, are putting the kids to sleep as they prepare to leave. As soon as the parents are gone, Wendy is woken up to Peter Pan and Tinkerbell rummaging through the bedroom. Wendy confronts Peter, and he explains he’s looking for his lost shadow. Wendy helps him reclaim his shadow, and in the process, wakes up her brothers, John and Michael. One thing leads to another, and before you know it, Peter is sprinkling a bunch of fairy dust on the children. They take flight, and with a magical poof, they soar out of the window, embarking on their journey to Neverland. Sounds familiar, doesn’t it?
While the plot of the show shares similarities with the movie, it also introduces its own unique twists. Notably, a conflict arises between Tiger Lily’s tribe and Peter Pan along with the Lost Boys. The ongoing battle involves accusations of theft between the groups. Surprisingly, once Captain Hook enters the scene, Tiger Lily’s Tribe and the Lost Boys decide to form an unlikely alliance and become best friends.
The unification of Tiger Lily’s tribe and Peter Pan and the Lost Boys is, in my opinion, the best scene in the play. This performance is packed with ambient singing and beautifully choreographed dance. The musical number called “Friends Forever” plays as they dance along and try to find a new handshake to seal their newly established bond. The song boasts a wonderful melody, seamlessly intertwining with the joyous celebration.
The cast of Peter Pan is wonderfully diverse, featuring actors from various racial backgrounds. This production breathes new life into the story, making it feel more inclusive and significantly more multicultural than the original 1953 animated movie. Every actor delivers an outstanding performance, with special recognition for the young Reed Epley, who has captivated audiences on stage since the tender age of four.
Captain Hook, played by Cody Garcia, is excellent. Garcia is everything you could ask for in an antagonist. He is funny, sassy, and downright evil. Throughout the show, we watch him sing and dance his way into wicked plots to kill all of the children. Surprisingly dark for a kids’ show, I must say. Every time Hook is on stage the crowd laughs, captured by his beguilement. He has what sounds like a Scottish pirate accent and owns it with every word. Garcia’s singing is also impressive with a surprising vocal range that has depth and great heights.
Nolan Almeida, portraying Peter Pan, showcases remarkable acting skills. His singing, dancing, and ability to charm the audience with magic are truly fascinating. Almeida flawlessly hits all his cues and fully embraces his character throughout the show.
My only disappointment stemmed from the choice for the character of Tinker Bell. Anticipating the fairy in physical form, I was surprised when the show opted for what appeared to be a flashlight’s glow instead. Despite my reservations, the children in the audience adored the fairy light, with some even declaring Tinker Bell as their favorite character.
The live orchestra is phenomenal. Their music does a wonderful job complementing the show with whimsical sounds and adventurous beats. Each song is sweetly crafted to help tell the story of Peter Pan, the Lost Boys, and the children versus the dreaded Captain Hook. The music by Morris (Moose) Charlap is perfect and brings the show to life.
Beyond the enchanting music, the choreography by Lorin Latarro truly captivates the audience. Every dance, intricately woven into the musical numbers, is a resounding success, executed flawlessly by the talented cast. The exhilarating flips and graceful couple dancing add an extra layer of excitement. Amidst the choreography, the simulated fights between characters during the show provide an entertaining spectacle. And let’s not forget the magical flying sequences, seamlessly orchestrated by Paul Rubin, which transport us into the heart of Neverland.
Costume design emerged as one of my favorite aspects of the show. Anticipating a vibrant array of colors, I was not disappointed. Sarafina Bush, the costume designer, delivers costumes that are not only true to each character but are also bursting with life. Tiger Lily’s group sports a unique tribal look, while the Lost Boys’ attire exudes wildness and adventure.
The set and stage design further enhances the experience. The lush green jungle landscape of Neverland and the cozy children’s bedroom stand out as exceptional set pieces. Each set was thoughtfully interactive, seamlessly accommodating every scene. And within the Nederlander Theatre, the ambiance feels like the perfect gateway to Neverland—just a sprinkle of fairy dust and a glimpse through French casement windows, and you’ll be soaring.
Kudos to director Lonny Price and executive producer Trinity Wheeler for breathing new life into Peter Pan. Their fresh adaptation transports the beloved characters into a modern world, embracing the timeless magic of imagination. Whether you’re a first-timer or a seasoned viewer, this show promises fun for all.
After the show, I chatted with a few audience members to gauge their thoughts on Peter Pan. Cindy exclaimed, “The show was fantastic, and they had a thrilling cast.”
Kelly, on the other hand, shared a different perspective: “It was a great show, but this wasn’t the same Peter Pan I remember from my childhood. It feels like I didn’t recall any of this happening.”
And then there was Steven, brimming with excitement: “This show was fabulous! It’s a classic story with a modern twist—an absolute must-see for all ages.”
In summary, I thoroughly enjoyed the show. Peter Pan: The Hit Broadway Musical rekindled my youthful spirit and left me wistful for the days of unbridled imagination. While the entire performance was entertaining, Act Two held a special place in my heart. My inner child reveled in the magic, and I departed with renewed inspiration to seek out more ways to stay forever young.
Catch Broadway in Chicago's Peter Pan is being performed March 26th through April 7th at James M. Nederlander Theatre. Performances are Tuesday through Thursday at 7:00 p.m. (with a Wednesday matinee at 1:00 p.m. on April 3rd), Fridays at 7:30 p.m., Saturdays at 2:00 p.m. and 7:30 p.m., and Sundays at 1:00 p.m. (with an additional performance on Sunday, March 31st at 6:30 p.m.).
The run time of the show is about two hours with a short 15-minute intermission. Make sure to arrive early as the line outside of the theatre is likely to be buzzing with anticipation.
Shattered Globe Theatre welcomes back one of Chicago’s own, Sarah Ruhl. “For Peter Pan on Her 70th Birthday” is a new play making its Midwestern debut at Theater Wit. Ms. Ruhl is one of the country’s foremost playwrights right now. She has another new play, “How to Transcend a Happy Marriage,” currently running at the Lincoln Center in New York. Her work is often produced in Chicago usually directed by her friend Jessica Thebus. This is an especially personal production for Ruhl as it stars her own mother (Kathleen Ruhl) in the title role.
No, this is not another warmed over incantation of the JM Barrie fairy tale. While somewhat influenced by the source material, “For Peter Pan on Her 70th Birthday” is a very realistic story of five siblings grappling with the death of their father. What begins in a depressing hospital room, moves to a whiskey-soaked conversation between siblings that eventually turns into a make-believe version of Peter Pan.
At its core, this is a play about love. There are plenty of plays about dysfunctional families, and this isn’t one of them. What it boils down to are five adult children trying to pinpoint a time when they felt their father’s love. These siblings have differing political beliefs and Ruhl’s apt commentary about our current climate is especially sharp, without being polarizing. There’s a great deal of truth in the courtesy her characters show for one another’s opinions. She also spends a great deal of the play dissecting the role of Catholicism and whether or not there is an afterlife. Despite the volley of bittersweet and at times painful memories of their childhood, these characters love each other and that is felt in the dialogue and performances.
Kathleen Ruhl is adorable as the oldest sister and former Peter Pan star, Ann. Perhaps it’s her relation to the playwright, or her commitment to character, but Kathleen Ruhl makes the audience question how much of this work is fiction and how much is fact? Eileen Niccolai, a Shattered Globe ensemble member, provides a lot of the humor, but also some of the more heartfelt moments as youngest sister Wendy. All the siblings are named for Peter Pan characters, which underscores Sarah Ruhl’s point that with their parents gone, they are orphans now and need to grow up.
Like any Sarah Ruhl work, there is a great deal of whimsy. With each new work, Ruhl continues to keep one foot on the ground and one in the clouds. “For Peter Pan on her 70th Birthday” is both prolific in its subject matter and also aesthetically striking it its presentation. The reality of the situation and the poignancy of the lines allows the audience to trust their narrator and fly when the time comes.
Shattered Globe’s “For Peter Pan on Her 70th Birthday is being performed at Theater Wit at 1229 W Belmont (773.975.8150) and has been extended through May 27th.
Overall Citadel Theatre’s ‘Dames at Sea’ has a smashingly great cast of singers and dancers, perfect for a musical comedy…
When Francesca Zambello, director of The Glimmerglass Festival, commissioned an opera about race in America, the country was reeling from…
Even 40 years later, the AIDS crisis continues to shape American life. Long before Hollywood brought AIDS stories to the…
I thoroughly enjoyed Drury Lane's enchanting stage production of Disney’s The Little Mermaid from start to finish. While few are…
Pegasus Theatre Chicago is proud to announce the authors and plays being presented at the 38th Annual Young Playwrights Festival, January 5 - 26,…
Get ready to dive into the holiday spirit like never before on December 7th and 8th with A Christmas Cabaret…
“Every Brilliant Thing,” places unusual demands on its lead character, Narrator. Jessie Fisher delivers a carefully calibrated performance from a…
Northlight Theatre, under the direction of Artistic Director BJ Jones and Executive Director Timothy J. Evans, continues its 2024–2025 season with Louisa May Alcott's…
Music Theater Works is proud to announce the cast and creative team for the final production of its 2024 season, Legally Blonde:…
After pausing its operations last year to reorganize and create a new business model, Chicago's Tony-Award winning Lookingglass Theatre Company, in association…
BrightSide Theatre has announced that it will perform the long-running hit Broadway musical JEKYLL AND HYDE in a concert presentation…
Hell in a Handbag Productions is pleased to open its 2024/25 Season with the 25th anniversary edition of Artistic Director David Cerda's* holiday classic Rudolph…
Sometimes history has a way of repeating itself and it’s not always for the better. Try as we might to…
Throughout our busy lives we often seek out the new. It is easy to see the allure. Beginnings offer a…
I've always had a deep fondness for the two timeless films Holiday Inn and White Christmas. These movies feature outstanding…
Due to popular demand, Steppenwolf Theatre is pleased to announce Jane Lynch's A SWINGIN' LITTLE CHRISTMAS has added a sixth and final performance to its nearly sold-out…
The Joffrey Ballet's critically acclaimed reimagined classic, The Nutcracker by two-time Tony Award®-winning choreographer Christopher Wheeldon, returns to the Lyric Opera House, 20 North…
Lifeline Theatre brings their first MainStage production of the 2024-25 season to the stage with Jacob Marley's Christmas Carol. Tom Mula's holiday tale…
Individual tickets for SHUCKED, the Tony Award® winning musical comedy The Wall Street Journal calls "flat out hilarious," will go on sale on…
Invictus Theatre Company’s latest production of The Tragedy of Macbeth, adapted and directed by Sarafina Vecchio, delivers a potent, intense…
Ngozi Anyanwu’s Leroy and Lucy, in its electrifying world premiere at Steppenwolf Theatre, takes the legendary tale of Robert Johnson’s…
I’ve delighted in Babes with Blades since they began in 1997, and they are never more delightful than when slashing…
Chicago Tap Allstars, a collective of Tap dance artists and organizations brought together by M.A.D.D. Rhythms and Chicago Tap Theatre, is proud to…
Steppenwolf Theatre Company, the nation's premier ensemble theater company, is pleased to continue its 49th season with the world premiere of Ngozi…
I’ll admit it: I knew little about “Into the Woods” before seeing the new production at Chicago’s Chopin Theatre. I’m…
Music Theatre Works’ Little Shop of Horrors, featuring music by Howard Ashman and a book and lyrics by Alan Menken,…
I’m actually not a dance critic. I don’t know enough about dance; I‘m not fluent in the language of dance;…
IDENTITY PERFORMING ARTS Presents Fall Concert “Embrace” World Premiere in Chicago for Two Performances Location: Ann Barzel Theater Visceral Dance Center,…
American Blues Theater announces its 23rd Annual Production of It's a Wonderful Life: Live in Chicago! from Frank Capra's film and directed by Executive Artistic…
Chicago Tap Theatre (CTT) has recently returned from a successful European Tour and is pleased to announce its 2024-2025 season and…
Does your theatre company want to connect with Buzz Center Stage or would you like to reach out and say "hello"? Message us through facebook or shoot us an email at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
*This disclaimer informs readers that the views, thoughts, and opinions expressed in the text belong solely to the author, and not necessarily to Buzz Center Stage. Buzz Center Stage is a non-profit, volunteer-based platform that enables, and encourages, staff members to post their own honest thoughts on a particular production.